Thread Rating:
Sporting Integrity
#11
This game won't happen anyway. The MLS over here will object to it being played here just like they did when the PL mooted the idea. To the MLS a game like this diminishes their standing and interferes with what they are trying to achieve over here.

(25-11-2015, 18:35)Trusevich Wrote: While we're on the NFL, as an aside, I find it remarkable that there are no amateur teams, no rural leagues, no pub leagues at all in that sport. You join your High School team, if you're lucky you get to be one of the 3-4% of players that then make their College teams, then you get to be one of the 7% who get drafted to an NFL team. If at any point you don't make the grade, there's no fall-back, there's no lower league to play in, there's no other route into the senior game That's it, you're done. You never play that sport again.

As I said, I find that remarkable.

Not quite true, players that don't make the NFL rosters have a number of options.  First is to make the practice squad that each NFL team has.  These squads are put together so that the first team can practice against decent players but without playing their first team offence against the first team defence.  It also allows the coaches to work in depth with the offence or the defence without having to worry about each other in terms of what they want to work on.  Secondly, players who do not make the NFL can go and play in Canada in the CFL, which is made up of mainly American players.  Thirdly they can sign up with a team in the Indoor league, a place a number of current NFL players went and eventually got into the NFL.

Of course the other part of the system is that all the players go through college and get an education so can turn their hand to a completely new field if they don't make it to the NFL.  Of course they don't always work too hard at other classes but they do get something out of 4 years at college.
Reply
#12
First I have heard of this, I take it that it is a scheduled SPFL1 game between Celtic and Dundee FC ?

It has reminded me of a thread I posted on the old site back in 2011 : No Integrity in 39

The EPL wanted to play a 39th game overseas for money. This, as I said at the time, showed that the money driven idiots advocating this 39th game had no concept of the principle behind league football, that everything must balance !!!


With the EPL 20 teams play 38 games each, 19 home, 19 away.
The bottom line of the League Table must always have :
Games Played = Won + Drawn + Lost.
Games Won = Games Lost
Goals For = Goals Against and Goal Difference = 0
Points Scored (2 for a win & 1 for a Draw) = Games Played ... how points should be allocated !!!
With 3 points for a win the equation is convoluted, e.g., Played + Won = Points ... whereas with 2 points the bottom line figures for Played and Points should be identical. With that, if the points figure is lower than played, then that would indicate points deductions, provided there were no errors in the table entries and/or the calculations.

Triesman and the 39th Game
AVFC RFC SAFC
Reply
#13
I just dinnae Ken how they can even contemplate this, they're just showing contempt for the fans that matter, oh, hang on a minute
Reply
#14
The fans are the twelfth man , every team gets a lift when the fans get behind the team and the other team gets intimidate, why do you think they state "home" advantage
Reply
#15
(25-11-2015, 22:05)doubledutch Wrote: The fans are the twelfth man , every team gets a lift when the fans get behind the team and the other team gets intimidate, why do you think they state "home" advantage

So if they were to do this, and its a big if, then make sure the fixture that it "replaces" is the normal home game for Celtic, that way it makes no difference from a home advantage standpoint.
Reply
#16
That's the only way it could be without any advantage, my whole point was it is Dundee's home game they are talking about
Reply
#17
But Dundee would claim all the gate receipts no?
Reply
#18
Its not about Dundee its about the fact that the big team would effectively have another"home" game instead of a potential tricky away game
Reply
#19
Can anybody explain the " it'll be good for the Scottish game" line that's being punted aboot . Cannae see that it'll make any difference tae the Scottish game apart fae pissing off the fans that trundle along tae watch their team every week. Nae consideration tae the community either, the local hostleries and eateries that rely on a match day tae boost their coffers
Reply
#20
IMO Celtic would be well supported over there I can only
imagine that they'll have decent backing from ex pays I don't imagine many ex pat Dundee fans,personally they should be told to bolt Scottish league games get played in eh Scotland
Reply
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)