[0762]

I was certain he was off during the game, but having seen other angles i reckon its like Berra said in that it was "too close to call". He looks just behind Ralston when he crosses it.

Madden was as dreadful as ever though. He made some shocking calls.

Hearts made some changes 2nd half and played quite well after, its stretching it for robbie to say they were on top though, first half sellick should have been out of sight  

It was a close call re that goal. Sure, an element of luck involved, but it was still a vg goal, well worked from Celtic's right flank and Kyogo's movement off the CBs was top class with a deadly strike past Gordon. In the overall context of this match, it was a deserved win. Note in Hertz last two visits to Celtic Park, IMO Craig Gordon's contribution has been immense. Otherwise they could well have lost upwards of about 10-12 goals in both these matches. Also note Hertz have never won at Celtic Park in over 14 years and one can see why when scrutinising the events of their past two visits where Celtic's % possession of the ball was massive. As for Madden, he was indeed shocking and he conveniently ignored some really glaring fouls as well as conveniently not applying the "advantage rule" properly and to Celtic's potential benefit. Anybody surprised? No!