+- Sports Babble - sports forum (https://www.sportsbabble.co.uk)
+-- Forum: Football (https://www.sportsbabble.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Scottish Football League (https://www.sportsbabble.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=24)
+---- Forum: Scottish Premiership (https://www.sportsbabble.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+----- Forum: Hibernian (https://www.sportsbabble.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=137)
+----- Thread: Scott McDonald (/showthread.php?tid=4315)
Scott McDonald - hibeejim21 - 26-06-2016
Heard we are trying to sign him on a free this week.
RE: Scott McDonald - Fredstersafool - 26-06-2016
I saw him last year don't do it he's pish
RE: Scott McDonald - HerefordBull - 26-06-2016
He speaks highly of you to Fred.
Wouldn't be too disappointed.....experience for the younger players and still scores goals, especially I expect coming down a division, though I don't think we would be relying on him to be our main striker. If Cummings ( if he stays) , Keatings and him all chipped in with a few we would be OK.
GGTTH
RE: Scott McDonald - Fredstersafool - 26-06-2016
Just telling you what I saw new have he was piss poor
RE: Scott McDonald - hibeejim21 - 26-06-2016
Id take mcdonald, 18 goals from just over 50 appearances for motherwell,suggests he still has something about him.
RE: Scott McDonald - 0762 - 26-06-2016
(26-06-2016, 13:48)newhavenhibby Wrote: He speaks highly of you to Fred.
Wouldn't be too disappointed.....experience for the younger players and still scores goals, especially I expect coming down a division, though I don't think we would be relying on him to be our main striker. If Cummings ( if he stays) , Keatings and him all chipped in with a few we would be OK.
GGTTH
Yep! A combination of experience and good striking prowess in the Championship could be beneficial to us. Also my more recent impression of McDonald was that he needs to lose weight and that would ultimately improve his form as a player.
RE: Scott McDonald - hfcbounce - 27-06-2016
Think he would be worth a punt. Even offered a one year contract if his goals get us up he gets another years contract works for both sides that way.
GGTTH
RE: Scott McDonald - HerefordBull - 28-06-2016
Grant Holt, ex Norwich City, now 35, has been linked as Lennons first signing.........not sure.
We do not need him and McDonald.
GGTTH
RE: Scott McDonald - hibeejim21 - 28-06-2016
Holt is a big,powerful player who has done the biz at a much higher level than our league. If he can stay fit (and he has had serious injury late in his career) he will do a job for us because he can both hold it up and head the ball. An option that was missing with farid last season.
Looks like lennon thinks we lack a bit of experience in the forward areas.
RE: Scott McDonald - HerefordBull - 28-06-2016
Agreed Jim.
Its his age and fitness I wonder about. I would take Holt or McDonald but not both. Their role would be identical.